Maddenation

Old, Older

Rarely do I achieve revelation while reading freshman papers (unless you count the revelation that I should not sign up to teach freshman composition again), but tonight I did. A student wrote about an “older” man talking to a “young” man, and I wanted him to make those adjectives parallel, probably by going with straight “old.” It was then that I realized the strange quality of our language whereby “older” can actually mean “younger than old.” It’s true! “Mr. Smith is an older gentleman” vs. “Mr. Jones is an old man.” Mr. Jones is actually older than Mr. Smith, right? Isn’t that weird?

p.s. And then I found twenty bucks.

PatrickWords03/01/06 2 comments

Comments

Dad • 03/01/06 12:38 PM:

True, “older” is younger than “old,” but I think it more often means “older then you are” or “older than the writer.” So it’s not so much a stand-alone word as it is a contraction of sorts for the longer phrase. Often, for example, we hear of someone dating an “older” woman/man. This clearly means someone more than a few years older than the subject; someone out of the reasonable upper band for age difference in a relationship. I hope I’m not being too captious.

Patrick • 03/02/06 10:14 AM:

You’re right, but those aren’t the only situations where you’d call someone “older” instead of “old.” Sometimes, there’s no direct comparison, and even someone of the same age could, in describing an absent, non-dating third party, say “he’s an older man, maybe in his early fifties” or something like that.

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

Please capitalize your name properly and use the same information each time you comment. We will not send you spam, and your email address will not be posted.


Remember me?

Formatting
*bold*=bold
_italic_=italic
"link":http://url.com=link


Related Entries
  1. Time’s Winged Arrow
    Why does time seem to move faster as we get older?
  1. Age and the Window for Adventure
    “Does Age Quash Our Spirit of Adventure?” is a story about why folks lose their spirit of adventure as they grow older.
  1. Clean up your language
    maddening English language errors you hear and read everyday
  1. Chaos and Language
    How does bilingualism influence our thoughts?
  1. Whence Language?
    Coetzee derives it from song and “the need to fill out with sound the overlarge and rather empty human soul.”
Validation

XHTML & CSS