Maddenation

I beg your question

I just read the following sentence in Michael Polan’s book, The Omnivore’s Dilemma: “This begs the question of why the problem has gotten so much worse in recent years.” Polan is a great writer, but in using the expression, “begs the question” he is falling prey to misusage that has become so common it has virtually destroyed the original meaning of the phrase.

This has happened because the literal definitions of the individual words suggest a simple meaning that is “obvious” to those not schooled in formal logic. This made-up alternate meaning also fulfills a need for a clever response to answers that are so unsatisfactory they, “beg us to ask a follow-up question.” However, this usage of the phase, compelling as it is, is nonetheless stomping all over the original meaning as defined by logicians. It means you’ve assumed the conclusion you’re trying to prove [you dummy]. It’s as bad as using the word presently to mean “now” instead of “soon.”

If you’d like to join the handfuls of people struggling to preserve the proper meaning of this phrase, you may wish to consult this site.

DadExplanations06/01/08 1 comments

Comments

David • 06/12/08 8:48 AM:

You know I agree with you Dad, but here’s what Webster’s has to say about presently

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

Please capitalize your name properly and use the same information each time you comment. We will not send you spam, and your email address will not be posted.


Remember me?

Formatting
*bold*=bold
_italic_=italic
"link":http://url.com=link


Related Entries
  1. Poetry and Meaning
    Dad and I were talking a little bit about the meaning of poetry because I gave him a poem to…
  1. Searching for Meaning
    Accept it’s brief invitation to a small adventure.
  1. Pluto is saved! [NOT]
    The key question is how the astrologers will take it.
  1. On the Border
    The fundamental question we ought to face is the legitimacy of protecting our borders at all.
  1. Happiness
    I may as well tell you that experts say you’ll be happier if you have friends at work. (Duh?)
Validation

XHTML & CSS